Historians debate over capitalism is heating up history. For a long time, historians mostly depicted slavery as a. The book, however, is not an essay in ideas or interpreta tion. Baptist born 1970 is an american academic and writer. He received his doctorate in history from oxford and taught at howard university in the united states before returning to his country. Sven beckert and seth rockman, editors, slaverys capitalism. In a new york times magazine article this month, matthew desmond provided an overview of recent work by historians of capitalism who argue that slavery was foundational to american growth and economic development in the nineteenth century. Slavery, capitalism, and the problem of misprision. Dec 14, 2017 i just ran across john cleggs credit market discipline and capitalist slavery in antebellum south carolina. Some scholars have always disagree with such accounts. Slaverys capitalism argues for slaverys centrality to the emergence of american capitalism in the decades between the revolution and the at the same time, the nation sustained an expansive and brutal system of human bondage. James and eric williams argued for the centrality of slavery to capitalism, though their findings were largely. How slavery gave capitalism its start the daily beast.
However, unlike post, clegg maintains that slavery was. In 1944 his book capitalism and slavery argued that the british abolition of their atlantic slave trade in 1807 was motivated primarily by economicsrather than by altruism or humanitarianism. John clegg, capitalism and slavery, in critical historical studies 2015 peter coclanis, slavery, capitalism, and the problem of misprision, in journal of american studies 2018 rosanne currarino, toward a history of cultural economy, in journal of the civil war era 2012. But while most scholars now agree that antebellum american slavery was in some sense capitalist, it. Anyone who has read beckert, baptist, and johnson, or is eagerly awaiting the forthcoming volume on slaverys capitalism, ought to read what clegg has to say. The new york times is right that slavery made a major contribution to capitalist development in the united states just not in the way they imagine. Plantation owners, shipbuilders, and merchants connected with the slave trade accumulated vast fortunes that established banks and heavy industry in europe and expanded the reach of capitalism worldwide.
Thoughts on john cleggs capitalism and slavery louis proyect. American plantation overseers and the production of cotton in british india. But what i particularly want to share with junto readers today is an article by the nyu sociologist john clegg recently published in the chicagobased journal, critical historical studies. Online shopping from a great selection at books store. John clegg on the role slavery played creating american capitalism. The relationship between slavery and capitalism has recently become a topic of both scholarly and to some extent public interest. How slavery shaped capitalism, by john clegg written for the farleft magazine jacobin, this essay by sociologist john clegg examines the treatment of capitalism by the nhc literature, as featured in desmonds essay. Cotton, slavery, and the new history of capitalism article in explorations in economic history 67 december 2017 with 342 reads how we measure reads. Mar 24, 2018 read the book here fifteen years ago i began writing a series of articles about capitalism and slavery to answer charles posts july 2003 journal of agrarian change article titled plantation slavery and economic development in the antebellum southern united states that applied the brenner thesis to the peculiar institution and its abolition.
Expropriation and exploitation in racialized capitalism. It argues that these authors fail to provide a coherent account of capitalism. Here are some thoughts on his typically robust response to criticism by alan olmstead and john clegg. The new history of capitalism grounds the rise of industrial capitalism on the production of raw cotton by american slaves.
This is the book that convinced me to go back to school and get a degree in economics. Review of capitalism and slavery by eric williams the. Clegg, new york university w as slavery capitalist. Clegg attacks my argument that intense coercion drove a 400% increase in the efficiency of. A panel from the historical materialism new york 20 conference. Theorizing capitalist slavery, john clegg the relationship between slavery and capitalism has recently become a topic of both scholarly and to some extent public interest. I attacked baptists book because i thought it fundamentally dishonest and an example of extremely poor historical practice. Slavery, capitalism, and politics in the antebellum.
Clegg, slavery and capitalism, critical historical studies 2. October 16, 2018 october 17, 2018 guy emerson mount activism, african diaspora, black intellectual history, reparations, slave trade, slavery reparations for slavery are arguably the biggest global question facing the african diaspora in the twentyfirstcentury. Capitalism and slavery university of north carolina press. The article provoked predictable wails of disapproval. Fifteen years ago i began writing a series of articles about capitalism and slavery to answer charles posts july 2003 journal of agrarian change article titled plantation slavery and economic development in. I just ran across john cleggs credit market discipline and capitalist. Based on a dissertation written at the university of oxford in 1938, entitled the economic aspect of the abolition of the british west indian slave. We have benefitted from the comments and suggestions of ran abramitzky, brad barham, sven beckert, hoyt bleakley, trevor burnard, john clegg, peter.
Rhode slave productivity in cotton picking, 2018 and the source of baptists data, john j clegg capitalism and slavery, 2015, and james oakes capitalism and slavery and the civil war, 2016. He led trinidad and tobago to independence within the. Capitalism and slavery was written by the first and former prime minister of trinidad and tobago, dr eric william. Capitalism and slavery critical historical studies.
The incompatibility of slavery and capitalism being libertarian. The clear connection between slavery and american capitalism. I just ran across john cleggs credit market discipline and capitalist slavery in antebellum south carolina. Thematically, he has been interested in the history of capitalism and has also been interested in digital humanities methodologies. And towards the end of his last published book, capital, he wrote. Thematically, he has been interested in the history of capitalism and has also been interested in.
Thoughts on john cleggs capitalism and slavery louis. The civil war should be seen as americas bourgeois revolution. Based on a dissertation written at the university of oxford in 1938, entitled the economic aspect of the abolition of the british west indian slave trade and slavery, the work is an economic study of the. Counter arguments can be found in articles by alan l. Continuing the debate on slavery and capitalism the junto. An example is the accumulation of capital via the means of savings, which in turn is the engine toward productivity growth. Read the book here fifteen years ago i began writing a series of articles about capitalism and slavery to answer charles posts july 2003 journal of agrarian change article titled plantation slavery and economic development in the antebellum southern united states that applied the brenner thesis to the peculiar institution and its abolition. The style of the business of slavery is often convoluted and cumbersome. Joe bidens political history is even more disgusting than you thought, with branko marcetic. Weve got another seven videos and a podcast out this week. Oct 27, 2015 but what i particularly want to share with junto readers today is an article by the nyu sociologist john clegg recently published in the chicagobased journal, critical historical studies. Jan 03, 2020 how slavery shaped capitalism, by john clegg written for the farleft magazine jacobin, this essay by sociologist john clegg examines the treatment of capitalism by the nhc literature, as featured in desmonds essay. Harry haywood, the struggle for the leninist position on the negro question in the united states, the communist, september 1933. Clegg, capitalism and slavery, critical historical studies 2, no.
A theory of capitalist slavery clegg 2020 journal of historical. Slavery, capitalism, and the problem of misprision volume 52 issue 3 peter a. Clegg got a lot of attention a couple of years ago for capitalism and slavery. While maybe not riveting it certainly is an information packed book. Our new print issue, political revolution, is out now. The main point of the book is that without slavery there is no capitalism. The wealth of capitalism came from the free labor of the slaves on the sugar, cotton and tobacco plantations. The incompatibility of slavery and capitalism being.
Cotton, slavery, and the new history of capitalism request pdf. So many books and articles have been published in recent years discussing. Asking new questions of the new history of capitalism. Recent works include sven beckerts empire of cotton, walter johnsons. Net by gavin wright, department of economics, stanford university. The content of the first 2030 pages gave the impression that the book had been. The opposite of capitalism is communism where you work for the state or commune or you dont get food there is no saving up for a rainy day there is no freedom there is no choice. John clegg like charles posts article in the latest catalyst behind a paywall. Its been two and a half years since the new history of capitalism.
Slavery, essentially, cannot be associated with capitalism because capitalism has many traits which obstruct the laws of slavery and vice versa. All content in this area was uploaded by john clegg on nov 16. Rosenthal is careful to note that her book is not an origin story, but that is how desmond reads it. For todays historians the question can evoke musty, longwinded debates from the 1970s. But while most scholars now agree that antebellum american slavery was in some sense capitalist, it is not at all clear what they mean by that. Capitalism is a sad commentary on human nature, and only serves to entrench the havenots for their entire lives. Consumers become enslaved by so many choices, and by becoming the victims of corporate america, who have ingrained people to believe they need things they dont need. Dr william, in a nutshell shows how the wealth of the west was gained by the exploitation and enslavement of the black man. This book, the first of a twovolume treatment of slavery, capitalism and politics, locates the political struggles of the antebellum period in the. While maybe not riveting it certainly is an information packed book that backs up its argument really well. The classic account and starting point for all modern discussions is eric williams, capitalism and slavery chapel hill, 1944.
Jenny brown on how abortion rights are under attack and why we cant rely on liberal ngos for the fight back. Though only a pale shadow of the dustup we had back in the 1970s, the aggressive assertions of the new history of capitalism regarding the centrality of slavery for u. Clegg discusses shortcomings in the works of several nhc scholars including ed baptist, sven beckert, and walter. So argues dr john ashworth in this novel reinterpretation, from a marxist perspective, of american political and economic development in the forty years before the civil war. Cotton, slavery, and the new history of capitalism. James and eric williams argued for the centrality of slavery to. Illustration of africanamerican slaves working on a cotton plantation circa 1840. This may seem to be a minor point but if its worth trying to trace the connections between capitalism and slavery, its worth making that analysis accessible beyond the narrow circle of specialists and academic historians. Sep 23, 2016 slavery, essentially, cannot be associated with capitalism because capitalism has many traits which obstruct the laws of slavery and vice versa. Capitalism and slavery and the civil war cambridge core. As i said above, i think he is a poor historian and that his book is. The relationship between slavery and capitalism has recently become a topic of both scholarly and public debate.
It is strictly an economic study of the role of negro slavery and the slave trade in providing the capital which financed the industrial revolution in england and of mature industrial capitalism in destroying the slave system. Like charles posts article in the latest catalyst behind a paywall, john cleggs capitalism and slavery that appeared in the fall 2015 critical historical studies criticizes the new historians of capitalism aka nhc edward baptist, walter johnson, sven beckert, et al from the standpoint of political marxism. Slavery, capitalism, and the problem of misprision journal. In desmonds words, slavery helped turn a poor fledgling nation into a financial colossus.
Jul 08, 2014 capitalism and slavery is the first and most important work by the late trinidadian scholar and statesman, eric eustace williams. Slavery helped finance the industrial revolution in england. This blog reported cleggs take on the half has never been told as a corrective. Dec 12, 2014 some scholars have always disagree with such accounts.
Slavery s capitalism argues for slavery s centrality to the emergence of american capitalism in the decades between the revolution and the at the same time, the nation sustained an expansive and brutal system of human bondage. Capitalism and slavery and the civil war semantic scholar. Slavery, capitalism, and imperialism international. By extension, so was the emancipation of the slaves and the fight against the trading in slaves by other nations. The ties between slavery and capitalism in the united states werent always crystal clear in our history books. A theory of capitalist slavery clegg 2020 journal of. Slavery and capitalism the chronicle of higher education. However, unlike post, clegg maintains that slavery was capitalist, thus. Capitalism and slavery is the first and most important work by the late trinidadian scholar and statesman, eric eustace williams. A number of recent books suggest that scholars have begun to recognize the. On the role of debt in the slave economy, see clegg, john j. Freedom is not slavery capitalism brought more people out of slavery than any other system. Two important collection of essays capture much of the debate aroused by williams.
671 688 199 1501 1403 1464 187 604 1133 829 1145 489 1476 1272 923 327 940 886 368 1330 115 1386 910 772 858 378 250 1164 1359 830 1086 232 1307 1113 686 1256 1432